(Review from progarchives.com)

The title of course refers to the “Demons and Wizards”/”Magician’s Birthday” period, which had brought Uriah Heep both their best music, and their biggest success to date. It is however is somewhat misleading, as there’s little in the way of wizards, demons, or indeed magicians. What there is however is a good collection of Uriah Heep songs.

With John Wetton on bass in place of Gary Thain, the band had the opportunity to exploit Wetton’s songwriting and vocal skills, but once again it’s Hensley’s songwriting which dominates the album. David Byron is still in fine form vocally, thus Wetton becomes almost a session player, providing bass and only occasional backing vocals.

Apart from the opening title track, side one of the LP contains much the weaker tracks on the album. “Return to fantasy” is a fine piece of faster paced Heep, with a driving rhythm, and pulsating keyboards. The remaining tracks on side one are a bit by-the-numbers Heep, although “Beautiful dream” has some good keyboards.

The second side is more diverse, with a couple of fine ballads allowing Byron to display his more sensitive side. The unaccompanied intro to “Why did you go” is particularly delicate, and would have been a challenge beyond most of Byron’s contemporaries. The final track, “A year or a day” builds superbly from a slow soft start to a climactic conclusion, with lyrical echoes of “The wizard”.

While “Return to Fantasy” is a fine album, it does not consistently meet the enormously high standards the band had set for themselves. There are some excellent moments, but there’s also an apparent lack of ambition at times, with some treading of water in evidence.

Line-up:
- David Byron / lead vocals
- Mick Box / guitars
- Ken Hensley / keyboards, guitars, synthesizer, vocals
- Lee Kerslake / drums, percussion, vocals
- John Wetton / bass, Mellotron, vocals

Track List:
01. Return To Fantasy (5:52)
02. Shady Lady (4:46)
03. Devil’s Daughter (4:48)
04. Beautiful Dream (4:52)
05. Prima Donna (3:11)
06. Your Turn To Remember (4:22)
07. Showdown (4:17)
08. Why Did You Go (3:53)
09. A Year Or A Day (4:22)

Link in comments.